NewsXbox

Gears of War: E-Day Reviews Are In: Great Shooting, Weaker Story

Critics rate the Gears prequel 88 on Metacritic and 87 on OpenCritic. The shooting gets near-universal praise, while the story, open areas and boss fights split reviewers. Here's the full breakdown, plus how Steam players reacted after launch.

Zerocade · Updated · 4 min read
ShareWhatsAppX

The short version

  • Critics rate it highly: 88 on Metacritic for Xbox Series X and 87 ("Mighty") on OpenCritic, with about 90% of critics recommending it.
  • Almost everyone praises the combat and movement. The most common complaints are the story, the open areas and damage-sponge bosses.
  • It launched on October 6 on Xbox Series X|S and PC (Xbox app and Steam), and on Game Pass Ultimate and PC Game Pass from day one. On Steam in India it costs ₹5,499, or ₹7,999 for the Premium Edition.
  • After launch, Steam players were less kind: Mostly Positive (74%), with crashes the top complaint.

What E-Day is

E-Day is a prequel set on Emergence Day, when the Locust Horde first burst out of the ground on the planet Sera. You play as a young Marcus Fenix and Dominic Santiago, alongside two new members of Bravo Squad, Mags Carter and Lucas Reyes. All four are playable.

The Coalition built it in Unreal Engine 5, with People Can Fly co-developing. It's one of the first games to ship with Epic's MegaLights lighting tech, and it uses hardware ray tracing. Xbox says it targets 4K and up to 60fps in the campaign on Series X.

Gears of War: E-Day key art, official Xbox image

Image: Microsoft / Xbox

The scores

Bar chart of Gears of War: E-Day review scores from ten outlets, from 95 to 70

Image: Zerocade

OutletScore
TechRaptor9.5/10
GamingTrend95/100
IGN9/10
GamingBolt9/10
Shacknews9/10
Eurogamer4/5
VGC4/5
PC Gamer77/100
Wccftech7.4/10
GameSpot7/10

The Xbox reviews on Metacritic were almost all positive, with just one mixed review at launch. The PC version scored lower, in the low-to-mid 80s, which lines up with the performance complaints below.

What critics agree on

The shooting. Reviewers keep coming back to how good the cover-and-shoot combat feels. GamingBolt calls it some of the tightest combat in the series and singles out the new movement: you can now slide, jump and climb, and sprint has moved to clicking the left stick. IGN says E-Day evolves the enemies, weapons and combat. TechRaptor goes furthest and calls it the best game in the series.

Pacing gets praise too. GamingBolt calls the campaign one of Gears' best-paced, and several reviewers liked how much horror there is early on, before the war gets going.

Where they split

The story is the big one. With Emergence Day as the setting, a lot of critics expected more. GameSpot calls the story disappointing. VGC says it takes a back seat and wanted more time spent on Marcus and Dom's friendship. Polish site GRY-Online felt Marcus gets pushed to the background, and Steam reviewers picked up the same thread about how much of the game focuses on Mags.

The open areas. Like Gears 5, E-Day has bigger hub-style sections between the linear levels. GameSpot found them fairly dull, and Windows Central was also unconvinced by these open-world-lite parts.

Bosses. Several reviews flag boss fights that soak up too much damage.

Length. Estimates vary a lot. One Italian review put the campaign at about 17 hours. TechRadar said about 25 hours with side content.

How launch went for players

Reviews only covered the campaign, because multiplayer servers weren't live during the review period. Multiplayer includes 4v4 Versus, four-player online co-op and two-player split-screen on console. There's also Horde Siege, a new 12-player mode with three squads defending the city of Kalona, with Assault, Breacher, Marksman and Medic classes.

Gears of War: E-Day hero image, official Xbox image

Image: Microsoft / Xbox

On Steam, the picture was rougher. About a week after launch, it sat at Mostly Positive (74%) across nearly 9,000 reviews. GameDaily went through the latest negative reviews and found crashes were the most common complaint, followed by the story. A Brazilian PC review also noted that ray tracing can't be turned off, so the game asks a lot of older graphics cards. The PC version also needs about 130GB of SSD space.

On PC, Nvidia is the official partner. The game supports DLSS 4.5 with frame generation, and also supports AMD FSR and Intel XeSS. Xbox's Advanced Shader Delivery pre-compiles shaders on supported stores to cut stutter on first launch.

Who it's for, on paper

If you're here for Gears combat, critics broadly agree it delivers. If you mainly play for the story, the reviews suggest you go in with lower expectations. On Game Pass Ultimate or PC Game Pass you can try it for yourself without paying ₹5,499. On PC, check that your graphics card supports ray tracing first.

For editions and early access, see our E-Day launch guide. What to watch next is the patch notes: crash fixes on PC, and how Horde Siege holds up once its seasonal content starts arriving.

Found this useful?
Send it to a friend who's been asking.
ShareWhatsAppX
Whodunit
Who did it? Place the suspects and catch the murderer.
Solve today's case →

Keep reading

Official Deltarune key art from the game's website
Up next

Deltarune Chapter 6 Is Now Playable From Start to Finish, Toby Fox Says, and Chapter 7 Work Has Begun: What's Left, Why There's Still No Date, and What It Costs in India

Toby Fox's Fall 2026 newsletter says Deltarune Chapter 6 is a 'structurally complete draft' you can play from beginning to end, with localization and testing next and a 2027 release still the aim. Chapter 7 has only just started. Here's exactly what was said, what's still missing, how earlier chapters launched, and why the ₹1,099 Steam version already covers it.

Official Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic Remake reveal art from the 2021 PlayStation Showcase

Star Wars: KOTOR Remake Rumoured for a Re-Reveal at The Game Awards on December 10: What the Leaker Said, Five Years of Delays, the '2028' Claim, and What the Originals Cost in India

21 Nov 2026
Official Grand Theft Auto VI key art from the Xbox store

Over 2 Million People Reportedly Used Xbox's 'New Zealand Trick' to Play GTA 6 Early: How It Works, Why It Was Easier on Xbox Than PS5, What Microsoft's Rules Say, and How Early It Got Players in India

21 Nov 2026
Official Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 4 reveal key art

Modern Warfare 4 Tops October's US Sales Chart in Nine Days, Wolverine Falls to 14th, and Xbox Hardware Spending Jumps 42%: Circana's October 2026 Numbers Explained

20 Nov 2026
Official Grand Theft Auto VI 'Now Available' artwork from Rockstar Newswire

GTA 6 Sold an Estimated 24.6 Million Digital Copies Worth $2.36 Billion by the End of Launch Day, Sensor Tower Says: What That Number Includes, the PS5 vs Xbox Split, and Why Take-Two Still Hasn't Said a Word

20 Nov 2026
Official Path of Exile 2 screenshot from its Steam store page

Path of Exile 2 Goes Free-to-Play on December 11, and Its Director Wants 1 Million Players on Steam: Acts 5 and 6, the Shadow and Duelist, a New Army League, and What Happens to Your Early Access Packs

20 Nov 2026