The short version
- Critics rate Gears of War: E-Day highly: 88 on OpenCritic (92% recommend) and 87 on Metacritic for Xbox Series X.
- On Steam it's Mostly Positive, at about 78% of the first 3,000 user reviews, slipping to 75% of 5,699 by October 8, per SteamDB.
- In one sample of negative reviews, 51 of 100 were about Mags Carter's role and the story, far more than performance or missing mechanics.
- Part of the negativity is a review bomb over the game being "woke", which has nothing to do with how it plays. E-Day costs $69.99 and is on Game Pass.
Two scores, two audiences
A 75-78% Steam score isn't bad. It's just a long way from the critic consensus we covered in our E-Day reviews roundup.
Image: Zerocade
The critics were enthusiastic about the core of the game. IGN gave it 9/10, as did GamingBolt, and VGC scored it 4/5, saying "very little beats it" for pure gunplay this year. GameSpot was cooler at 7/10, summing it up as "distinctly Gears", for better or worse. The PC version's Metacritic average is lower, at 83, which hints at some PC-specific problems.
There's a quirk worth knowing about Steam, too. Gagadget noted that the reviews Steam shows as "most helpful" lean negative, so the store page can look grimmer than the overall number. If you only read the top few, you'll get a skewed picture.
Plenty of people are playing
The split isn't a sign nobody's playing. During the early-access window for Premium Edition buyers, E-Day reportedly hit 20,374 concurrent players on Steam, roughly double Gears 5's PC record. SteamDB later logged a peak of 31,517 after the full launch on October 6. And those numbers don't count Game Pass players on PC and Xbox, which is where most Gears fans will be.
Image: Xbox Game Studios
What players are unhappy about
French site Kami Labs read the first 100 English-language negative reviews and sorted them by complaint. The result is lopsided.
Image: Zerocade
Setting aside the culture-war posts, a few themes keep coming up:
- Mags Carter. The new character's bigger role reads to some players as a bait and switch for a game sold on Marcus and Dom's origin story.
- Marcus and Dom. A common complaint is that both feel toned down compared with the older games.
- The story. Some call it dull next to the critics' praise.
- Missing staples. Players say chainsaw duels and the "meat shield" grab didn't make it in.
- PC performance. Around one in eight negative reviews mention it, which fits the lower PC Metacritic score.
These are fair arguments to have about a Gears game, and they don't cancel out the critics. Reviewers mostly judged the campaign and the combat, and both came out well. Steam players are weighing what feels like Gears to them.
The review bomb part
TheGamer and Game Rant both reported a wave of negative reviews calling the game "woke". Reviews like that usually target the cast and writing rather than anything you'd notice with a controller in hand, and they overlap with the Mags Carter complaints, which makes the two hard to separate.
Steam has a system for this. When Valve flags a burst as "off-topic review activity", those reviews are left out of the score by default, though you can choose to include them.
Should the split change your plans?
On paper, not much. If you're on Game Pass, trying it costs nothing extra. If you're buying on Steam, the PC performance complaints are the ones worth checking against your hardware, since they're the only ones a patch can fix.
What to watch
Whether the Steam score climbs once the launch crowd has finished the campaign, and whether a PC performance patch lands. On Steam, the Recent reviews figure often tells you more than the all-time number.






